Feedback on GrungeBDcraft 1.17 & 1.18

Topics regarding GrungeBDcraft, the semi-realistic resourcepack for Minecraft Java Edition.
Locked 
User avatar
BDcraft Web Admin
6829 Posts
 x 389

Post 21 Sep 2021, 17:14

Image
MC1.17 - The Cave and Cliffs - but everyone only cares about Axolotl - update

Welcome to the feedback thread for the 1.17 & 1.18 release of GrungeBDcraft! :)

The team that created this pack is HanFox, Lizannamae, Sphax, and StickerMonster!

This is currently an exclusive for BDcraft Supporters! :heart:


If you have any feedback, comments, ideas, or opinions about the latest version of GrungeBDcraft please post in the thread.

If you find any bugs please post them in the Bug Reports section or Discord.

Issues we already know about

Issues Pending Fix
  • Some textures in 512x are 256x instead due to lack of source files
  • Chests are missing
  • Sugar Canes/Reeds don't tile well
  • Iron Bars have obvious seams
  • Fences textures have obvious seams
  • Warped and Crimson Stem textures have obvious seams
  • Item Frames aren't modelled/textured fully
  • Sweep, bubble_pop, nautilus particles are missing
  • Drowned left arm and leg textures need mirroring
  • Most skins can't see out of the Iron helmet
  • GUI is generally unskinned
  • Unlit campfire has no breaking particles
Fixed in Downloads
  • Filled Map is broken -- fixed in 1.17r2
  • Chain item looks odd -- fixed in 1.17r2
  • End Crystal item looks odd -- fixed in 1.17r2
Game Bugs
:speech_balloon: Join the BDcraft Discord server to be kept up-to-date with news and to chat with other fans!

Profile pic by TsaoShin: https://www.deviantart.com/tsaoshin
If you like our work please consider becoming a Supporter and get an ad-free experience.
User avatar
Supporter
14 Posts
 x 0

Post 02 Oct 2021, 11:17

Can I leave some feedback. I think you've made a mistake putting this behind a paywall. I understand that this will not be your most popular texture pack, and I also understand that countless hours will have gone into making this. I'm not saying that I should expect you to work for nothing, not at all. I've been a supporter a few times over the years, purely as a thank you for previous versions of this texture pack.

My concern is that with this being behind a paywall, many people who want this, may not be able to afford this, nor may they want to "risk it" to see if the pack suits them on a gamble. This leads to my next fear. With many people not getting the supporter role, it may look like people are uninterested in this pack, and that concerns me for future updates to this. If you see that not many people have it, then I will guarantee that you won't waste your time updating a pack "no-one" wants. I have already waited for MANY years to get this update and the last thing I want is another abandonment of it.

Again, I'm not saying that you should work for free, or work updating a pack just for me. I just think that with a new release of something that people may be unfamiliar with, leaving it behind a paywall could stop people from getting it.

Cheers,
Z.
User avatar
BDcraft Web Admin
6829 Posts
 x 389

Post 02 Oct 2021, 11:35

Zianious wrote:
02 Oct 2021, 11:17
Can I leave some feedback. I think you've made a mistake putting this behind a paywall. I understand that this will not be your most popular texture pack, and I also understand that countless hours will have gone into making this. I'm not saying that I should expect you to work for nothing, not at all. I've been a supporter a few times over the years, purely as a thank you for previous versions of this texture pack.

My concern is that with this being behind a paywall, many people who want this, may not be able to afford this, nor may they want to "risk it" to see if the pack suits them on a gamble. This leads to my next fear. With many people not getting the supporter role, it may look like people are uninterested in this pack, and that concerns me for future updates to this. If you see that not many people have it, then I will guarantee that you won't waste your time updating a pack "no-one" wants. I have already waited for MANY years to get this update and the last thing I want is another abandonment of it.

Again, I'm not saying that you should work for free, or work updating a pack just for me. I just think that with a new release of something that people may be unfamiliar with, leaving it behind a paywall could stop people from getting it.

Cheers,
Z.
We aren't looking at how well GrungeBDcraft does on Java for if we keep the pack updated or not. We don't track download information at all for Java, besides bandwidth usage of all activity on our download servers.

Currently the only thing that will stop us updating the packs is if we literally have no artists to work on them, and we don't foresee that being an issue any time soon ;)
:speech_balloon: Join the BDcraft Discord server to be kept up-to-date with news and to chat with other fans!

Profile pic by TsaoShin: https://www.deviantart.com/tsaoshin
User avatar
Supporter
14 Posts
 x 0

Post 02 Oct 2021, 12:23

HanFox wrote:
02 Oct 2021, 11:35

We aren't looking at how well GrungeBDcraft does on Java for if we keep the pack updated or not. We don't track download information at all for Java, besides bandwidth usage of all activity on our download servers.

Currently the only thing that will stop us updating the packs is if we literally have no artists to work on them, and we don't foresee that being an issue any time soon ;)
Phew, phew, phew. I'm thankful for your quick and honest response. That's honestly reassuring to me to hear that you don't take download amounts into consideration.

I do still think that you should do things like, "for a week in December, get Grunge for free" or something like that to get the amount of players using it up. I can imagine that there are many people that would love to use this pack that cannot afford to do so. It's also sad for me to think that there could be re-uploads of this in places, but by nefarious people who edit the files to include malware. I've seen posts by people who have fell victim to that on places even like Curseforge (although I do not know if these have been false positives from people using random anti-viruses, or from just unexperienced computer users etc).

Thanks for replying so fast,
Z.
User avatar
Supporter
37 Posts
 x 8

Post 25 Oct 2021, 21:58

1) OMG, GrungeBDcraft is on FIRE! It BURNS AND STINGS it's so hot! Among those of us who've paid, it is now the exclusive pack we use on our server. I liked it so much, I bought it on Bedrock for my wife and I even though we don't play on Bedrock very much at all. Actually, we bought it for Bedrock before it was offered for Java. Grunge for us is just that smokin'!

2) One of the players on our server and another player, my wife's adult son are not supporters. I'm not really comfortable with the idea of making and "gifting" supporter accounts to them, that would be ... weird. Is there information or a link on how we might donate on their behalf so we can morally (and with permission) gift them copies of GrungeBDcraft?

3) I look forward to when "3d", "Better Leaves" and other such packs are offered. I miss them, but GrungeBDcraft is simply too good to worry about the "frills" for right now.

4) I dream of Normal Maps, Specular... or whatever the hell makes blocks "extra special" with ray tracing active.

5) Last, I'd like to mention GrungeBDcraft is pretty hot! Thank you for your 1.17 release.
User avatar
BDcraft Web Admin
6829 Posts
 x 389

Post 26 Oct 2021, 07:58

Romaq wrote:
25 Oct 2021, 21:58
1) OMG, GrungeBDcraft is on FIRE! It BURNS AND STINGS it's so hot! Among those of us who've paid, it is now the exclusive pack we use on our server. I liked it so much, I bought it on Bedrock for my wife and I even though we don't play on Bedrock very much at all. Actually, we bought it for Bedrock before it was offered for Java. Grunge for us is just that smokin'!
StickerMonster and Lizannamae, who put the most artistic talent in to the pack, will be delighted to hear it. I'll pass the message long. :D
Romaq wrote:
25 Oct 2021, 21:58
2) One of the players on our server and another player, my wife's adult son are not supporters. I'm not really comfortable with the idea of making and "gifting" supporter accounts to them, that would be ... weird. Is there information or a link on how we might donate on their behalf so we can morally (and with permission) gift them copies of GrungeBDcraft?
Firstly I'd just ask them if they're willing to make accounts so you can buy them some Supporter. They might be interested in the additional benefits :P

If not you can just gift Supporter to myself or Sphax as a "donation". We should probably make a note of that somewhere. There are likely others who may want to donate who don't want accounts :thinking:
Romaq wrote:
25 Oct 2021, 21:58
3) I look forward to when "3d", "Better Leaves" and other such packs are offered. I miss them, but GrungeBDcraft is simply too good to worry about the "frills" for right now.
I don't know when/if we'll do addons for Grunge. As the basic pack is still being worked over to smooth out stuff it could be a while before we're ready.
Romaq wrote:
25 Oct 2021, 21:58
4) I dream of Normal Maps, Specular... or whatever the hell makes blocks "extra special" with ray tracing active.
Maybe one day :P
Romaq wrote:
25 Oct 2021, 21:58
5) Last, I'd like to mention GrungeBDcraft is pretty hot! Thank you for your 1.17 release.
:hugging:
:speech_balloon: Join the BDcraft Discord server to be kept up-to-date with news and to chat with other fans!

Profile pic by TsaoShin: https://www.deviantart.com/tsaoshin
User avatar
Supporter
37 Posts
 x 8

Post 12 Dec 2021, 01:12

Happy to say... purchased a Supporter account for a relative just so he could enjoy GrungeCraft! Very happy, looking forward to updates. :)
User avatar
4 Posts
 x 0

Post 21 Dec 2021, 14:43

Hi team... I am really enjoying GrungeBDCraft, and wanted to know if there's any ETA on when chests are going to be added to Java edition?
User avatar
BDcraft Web Admin
6829 Posts
 x 389

Post 23 Dec 2021, 09:05

kainarg wrote:
21 Dec 2021, 14:43
Hi team... I am really enjoying GrungeBDCraft, and wanted to know if there's any ETA on when chests are going to be added to Java edition?
There isn't an ETA for anything currently.

A lot of things are being reworked after Nitro didn't provide his source files before mysteriously disappearing. Things are just being done as we get to them.
:speech_balloon: Join the BDcraft Discord server to be kept up-to-date with news and to chat with other fans!

Profile pic by TsaoShin: https://www.deviantart.com/tsaoshin
User avatar
1 Post
 x 0

Post 09 Feb 2022, 13:44

Hello, I've been know for both PureBDCraft and VanillaBDCraft I've used. I'm still waiting for the final results for GrungeBDCraft and how long it will be finish since then? I'm curious
Locked